Scales of Justice

Reputation for Excellence

Myths and Facts Surrounding Medical Malpractice Insurance

Request Consultation / 856-317-6558
Rating Methodology

Myths and Facts Surrounding Medical Malpractice Insurance

“Neon Insurance Office Sign” by David Hilowitz is licensed under CC BY 2.0

Medical malpractice suits can result in judgments ranging in the millions of dollars. As such, most practitioners have some type of medical malpractice insurance to cover them in the event they are sued. If you’ve recently been the victim of medical malpractice, you may be wondering how this insurance works, so here are some of the facts and myths surrounding it to help you become better informed.

What is Medical Malpractice Insurance?

Also known as medical liability insurance, it covers healthcare providers who make errors in treating patients, or are negligent in providing them care. It generally covers the cost of litigation in addition to providing damages to victims. A few of the things it covers includes (but is not limited to):

  • Misdiagnosis
  • Administering the wrong medication
  • Failure to read test results properly
  • Delays in treatment that cause a worsening of symptoms
  • Surgical errors
  • Wrongful death

Not just for Doctors

While medical malpractice insurance is typically thought of as being something for doctors, it is actually used by others in the healthcare industry as well. Physicians are not the only ones who can be targeted in a medical malpractice lawsuit, which is why nurses, lab technicians, physician’s assistants and medical technicians sometimes carry coverage as well. While these workers were once considered extensions of the doctors they worked for, they are now thought of as being independently licensed professionals, and can therefore be held liable for medical errors.

Although other healthcare workers may carry medical malpractice insurance, they usually have less coverage, since their potential liability is actually much smaller than a physician’s is. Institutions also have their own coverage, which may or may not cover individual employees. Many healthcare workers believe they are automatically covered under their employer’s plan, and are shocked to discover they have little or no representation from an insurance company once a malpractice claim has been filed.

Deciding who to Sue

A decision as to which healthcare professionals are named in a lawsuit is not done based upon who has medical malpractice insurance and who doesn’t. Instead, attorneys look at the facts of each individual case in order to determine who may have been liable for an incident. All of these people are then included in a subsequent complaint, since litigants have only one chance to present their case in court. This means it would not be possible to bring a separate lawsuit arising from the same facts later.

Information about medical malpractice coverage does not come until the discovery phase of litigation. This is when parties from both sides exchange information so that there are no surprises at trial. Even if it is discovered that one or more individuals is not insured, he or she will still be named as a defendant, and could therefore still be liable. These individuals could be required to pay damages out of their own pockets, and could be subject to wage garnishments or having property seized if they are unable to do so.

Medical Malpractice Insurance and Frivolous Lawsuits

There is some concern about the effects of frivolous lawsuits on our court systems, particularly when it comes to medical malpractice. As a result, some people believe that others are being encouraged to file frivolous lawsuits, simply because they think all medical practitioners are insured. The truth is that medical malpractice cases make up only around six percent of all tort claims, according to information from the National Center for State Courts. In addition, advocates for patient safety believe that very few people who are injured due to medical negligence actually sue. Harvard researchers have estimated that only one in eight people who are victims of medical negligence will subsequently file a lawsuit.

Those who do file medical malpractice suits are likely to have suffered serious injury or the death of a loved one. Harvard researchers also found that 80 percent of all medical lawsuits fell into one of those two categories, and that 97 percent of all claims in general were meritorious in nature. This means there is little to support the idea that having medical malpractice insurance opens a provider up to the possibility of a frivolous lawsuit.

Effect on Health Care Costs

There is a common misconception that rising health care costs are largely due to the high price of medical malpractice insurance, which health care providers ultimately pass on to their patients. According to a report from the American Association for Justice on Medical Negligence, the total amount spent defending claims of medical negligence in 2007 amounted to just 0.3% of health care costs. The AAJ does not recommend setting caps on damages, since the amount of money this would save the public is only negligible at best.

Another argument claims that the threat of medical malpractice suits causes doctors to practice “defensive medicine”, which involves them ordering unnecessary tests in order to avoid a potential lawsuit. The American Association for Justice also claims this has little bearing on the overall cost of health care. Instead, they claim that a good number of unnecessary tests are ordered in order to generate more income rather than out of a fear of being sued.

Costs Causes Doctors to Flee

Another common myth about medical malpractice insurance is that its high cost is causing a good number of doctors to leave the profession, leaving people in many areas with a shortage of health care providers. The American Association for Justice on Medical Negligence also debunks this myth. They claim there are now twice as many doctors per 100,000 people as there was in the 1960s when the American Medical Association first began tracking this data.

In addition, capping the amount of damages does not seem to have a bearing on whether or not physicians leave the practice. In fact, the number of doctors per 100,000 population tends to be higher in states that do not have caps on damages than in states that do have caps.

Tort Reform is needed to Lower Premiums

Tort reform has been touted as a successful measure when it comes to reducing medical malpractice insurance premiums. This has not proven to be beneficial in the past as:

  • Medical professionals in states with caps on damages pay roughly the same amount for premiums as others in states with caps do
  • GE Medical Protective, a leading provider of medical malpractice insurance informed the Texas Insurance Commissioner that caps in that state had very little impact on rates.
  • Tort reform is estimated to save a mere 1.0 percent in insurance costs each year
  • Major insurance companies have claimed that their rates would not necessarily decrease if tort reform was passed

Tort reform would actually hurt you as a patient if you are injured at the hands of a practitioner. This is because it would limit the amount of damages you would receive. This could be detrimental if you have debilitating injuries, since the amount awarded might not be enough to cover subsequent medical care or pain and suffering. Instead, the amount of damages should be determined by a jury, who can review the entire set of circumstances and ensure victims are fairly compensated.

Advice for Victims

Providers of medical malpractice insurance tend to fight aggressively to keep from paying claims. In some cases, they will even spend more money litigating a case than they would settling it, simply so that others will not be encouraged to file similar suits. Fighting a medical malpractice insurer can result in a long and difficult battle, which is why you need an aggressive attorney of your own. Doing so can make the difference between living in pain and agony or obtaining the compensation you deserve.

standing around table

Sharon Smith

Mike Berger and staff were professional, pleasant, strategic and knowledgeable. The office always kept me informed about my case and moved the case along quicker than I expected. I would highly recommend them to anyone !!

Kathryn N.

Thank you from the bottom of my heart. Reliable, honest, driven, knowledgeable, compassionate, and highly respected among colleagues and medical professionals [...] fought for me during times when I wasn’t strong enough to fight for myself. The Andres, Berger & Tran law firm understands Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS) [...] thank you for your support and guidance over the years.

Mike V.

Mike Berger of Andres, Berger & Tran handled my case over a six year period. He and the team examined every detail to get the best outcome. They were honest, candid and communicative throughout the whole process. It was a long ordeal but could not have been handled more professionally. I highly recommend.

Yadira R.

I just want to say thank you for what you have done for me and my family throughout the years. You made us feel like family, not just clients. You were always very detailed when it came to our cases and tried everything in your power to get us all the help we needed.

Gregory W.

Our family appreciated your unfailing attention to detail. There were last minute snags, we seldom worried that something would fall through the cracks, but you anticipated every contingency. Your firm demonstrated a veracity for the truth, a strong work ethic and overall impeccable character in dealing with our case.

01 / 05

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

case results

View All Case Results



Gas Explosion



Baby Brain Injury



Anesthesia Malpractice



Anesthesia Malpractice



Complex Regional Pain Syndrome



Anesthesia Malpractice

Areas We Serve

  • Burlington County
  • Bass River
  • Beverly
  • Bordentown City
  • Bordentown Township
  • Burlington City
  • Burlington Township
  • Chesterfield
  • Cinnaminson
  • Delanco
  • Delran
  • Eastampton
  • Edgewater Park
  • Evesham
  • Fieldsboro
  • Florence
  • Hainesport
  • Lumberton
  • Mansfield
  • Maple Shade
  • Medford Lakes
  • Medford Township
  • Moorestown
  • Mount Holly
  • Mount Laurel
  • New Hanover
  • North Hanover
  • Palmyra
  • Pemberton Borough
  • Pemberton Township
  • Riverside
  • Riverton
  • Shamong
  • Southampton
  • Springfield
  • Tabernacle
  • Washington Township
  • Camden County
  • Ashland
  • Audubon
  • Audubon Park
  • Barclay CDP
  • Barrington
  • Bellmawr
  • Berlin
  • Blackwood
  • Brookfield
  • Brooklawn
  • Camden
  • Cherry Hill
  • Chesilhurst
  • Clementon
  • Collingswood
  • Echelon
  • Ellisburg
  • Gibbsboro
  • Glendora
  • Gloucester City
  • Golden Triangle
  • Greentree
  • Haddon Heights
  • Haddonfield
  • Hi-Nella
  • Kingston Estates
  • Laurel Springs
  • Lawnside
  • Lindenwold
  • Magnolia
  • Merchantville
  • Oaklyn
  • Pine Hill
  • Pine Valley
  • Runnemede
  • Somerdale
  • Springdale
  • Stratford
  • Tavistock
  • Wood-Lynne
  • Cape May County
  • Avalon
  • Cape May Point
  • Cape May
  • Dennis Township
  • Lower Township
  • Middle Township
  • North Wildwood
  • Ocean City
  • Sea Isle City
  • Stone Harbor
  • Upper Township
  • West Cape May
  • West Wildwood
  • Wildwood Crest
  • Wildwood
  • Woodbine
  • Cumberland County
  • Bridgeton
  • Cedarville
  • Fairton
  • Laurel Lake
  • Millville
  • Port Norris
  • Rosenhayn
  • Seabrook Farms
  • Shiloh
  • Vineland
  • Gloucester County
  • Beckett
  • Clayton
  • Gibbstown
  • Glassboro
  • Mullica Hill
  • National Park
  • Newfield
  • Oak Valley
  • Paulsboro
  • Pitman
  • Richwood
  • Swedesboro
  • Turnersville
  • Victory Lakes
  • Wenonah
  • Westville
  • Williamstown
  • Woodbury
  • Woodbury Heights
  • Mercer County
  • Groveville
  • Hamilton Square
  • Hightstown
  • Hopewell
  • Lawrenceville
  • Mercerville
  • Pennington
  • Princeton
  • Princeton Junction
  • Robbinsville
  • Trenton
  • Twin Rivers
  • White Horse
  • Yardville
  • Ocean County
  • Barnegat
  • Barnegat Light
  • Bay Head
  • Beach Haven
  • Beach Haven West
  • Beachwood
  • Cedar Glen Lakes
  • Cedar Glen West
  • Crestwood Village
  • Dover Beaches North
  • Dover Beaches South
  • Forked River
  • Harvey Cedars
  • Holiday City South CDP
  • Holiday City-Berkeley CDP
  • Holiday Heights
  • Island Heights
  • Lakehurst
  • Lakewood
  • Lavallette
  • Leisure Knoll
  • Leisure Village
  • Leisure Village East
  • Leisure Village West
  • Manahawkin
  • Mantoloking
  • Mystic Island
  • New Egypt
  • North Beach Haven
  • Ocean Acres
  • Ocean Gate
  • Pine Beach
  • Pine Lake Park
  • Pine Ridge at Crestwood
  • Point Pleasant Beach
  • Point Pleasant
  • Seaside Heights
  • Seaside Park
  • Ship Bottom
  • Silver Ridge
  • South Toms River
  • Surf City
  • Toms River
  • Tuckerton
  • Vista Center
  • Waretown
  • Salem County
  • Alloway
  • Carneys Point
  • Elmer
  • Hancocks Bridge
  • Olivet
  • Pedricktown
  • Penns Grove
  • Pennsville
  • Quinton
  • Salem
  • Woodstown
  • Philadelphia
  • Bella Vista
  • Callowhill
  • Chinatown
  • East Passyunk
  • Fairmount
  • Fishtown
  • Graduate Hospital
  • Logan Square
  • Market East
  • Midtown Village
  • Northern Liberties
  • Old City
  • Pennsport
  • Powelton Village
  • Queen Village
  • Rittenhouse Square
  • Society Hill
  • Spring Garden
  • Spruce Hill and Cedar Park
  • University City
  • Washington Square West
  • Bucks County
  • Bristol
  • Brittany Farms - The Highlands CDP
  • Chalfont
  • Churchville
  • Cornwells Heights
  • Croydon
  • Doylestown
  • Dublin
  • Eddington
  • Fairless Hills
  • Feasterville
  • Hulmeville
  • Ivyland
  • Langhorne
  • Langhorne Manor
  • Levittown
  • Milford Square
  • Morrisville
  • New Britain
  • New Hope
  • Newtown
  • Newtown Grant
  • Penndel
  • Perkasie
  • Plumsteadville
  • Quakertown
  • Richboro
  • Richlandtown
  • Riegelsville
  • Sellersville
  • Silverdale
  • Spinnerstown
  • Trevose
  • Trumbauersville
  • Tullytown
  • Village Shires
  • Warminster Heights
  • Woodbourne
  • Woodside
  • Yardley
  • Montgomery County
  • Ambler
  • Arcadia University CDP
  • Ardmore
  • Audubon
  • Blue Bell
  • Bridgeport
  • Bryn Athyn
  • Bryn Mawr
  • Collegeville
  • Conshohocken
  • Eagleville
  • East Greenville
  • Evansburg
  • Flourtown
  • Fort Washington
  • Gilbertsville
  • Glenside
  • Green Lane
  • Halfway House
  • Harleysville
  • Hatboro
  • Hatfield
  • Haverford College CDP
  • Horsham
  • Jenkintown
  • King of Prussia
  • Kulpsville
  • Lansdale
  • Maple Glen
  • Montgomeryville
  • Narberth
  • Norristown
  • North Wales
  • Oreland
  • Penn Wynne
  • Pennsburg
  • Plymouth Meeting
  • Pottsgrove
  • Pottstown
  • Red Hill
  • Rockledge
  • Royersford
  • Sanatoga
  • Schwenksville
  • Skippack
  • Souderton
  • Spring House
  • Spring Mount
  • Stowe
  • Telford
  • Trappe
  • Trooper
  • West Conshohocken
  • Willow Grove
  • Woxall
  • Wyncote
  • Wyndmoor
Firm Award
Firm Award
Firm Award
Firm Award
Firm Award
Firm Award
Firm Award
Firm Award
Firm Award
Firm Award
View Rating Methodology

No aspect of this advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court of New Jersey